Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

In ancient cultures it was considered normal to leave a baby to die if you didn't want to raise it. Should we bring that back too?


That’s a bit of a false equivalency, isn’t it?

Besides, modern times have allowed us to avoid raising children if we don’t want to. We just don’t have to wait until the baby is a fully formed human and born from its mother’s womb to make that decision. In practice it may feel better to do it that way, but the basic effects are the same.


Abortion serves, in modern society, essentially the same function as abandonment.


Our law does not consider those things equivalent and I bet if you went around and asked many people would not consider that equivalent either.


Naturally a society which practices abortion but not abandonment would think so. But in both cases the function is essentially to provide a mechanism for infanticide to a society in which infanticide is prohibited (or rather, abhorred). There is a rationalization (for us, that the fetus isn't a child; for them, that the child is not actually killed, its life being turned over to the gods or to fate) but the rationalization is secondary to the fact that the act leaves the parent within, or on the border of, the normal workings of society instead of outside them altogether.


I don't agree, but I think my argument would work equally well if we took the example of being born into slavery.


Or adoption. Or I mean... it's not like people don't still abandon their babies if they really want to.


You can even avoid legal consequences by abandoning them at a fire station: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Safe-haven_law


Yes, but in the Roman world they left them at trash dumps and if they didn't simply die of exposure they were free for anyone to take as slaves. So I think we're still doing a bit better.


So... you're saying that society provides a more humane option so that we no longer leave children to die of exposure. Unlike in the past.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: