This is interesting; I haven't been really been following the lists recently but I took the time to read the linked thread and the pull request. While the functionality contained in the pull request is interesting, it's not quite the same as swizzling since it's done unconditionally at load time rather than runtime (so it's much more similar to DYLD_INTERPOSE in that sense). While this covers many of the cases when swizzling is necessary, it leaves out a rather important one where the correct method override is selected at runtime, generally conditionally.
Also, as a sidenote, it seems that there is some sort of motivation to have compiler type checks for the replacement, i.e. @_dynamicReplacement(for: bar())–how will this actually work in practice? If I compile a bundle without access to the source of the application I'm going to be loaded into, how would bar() be accessible to the compiler at all?
> That’s just dlsym().
Sorry, I should have been more clear: can I grab a function pointer to an unexported function?
> > Can I "swizzle"?
> There’s an experimental thing for this now: https://github.com/apple/swift/pull/20333
This is interesting; I haven't been really been following the lists recently but I took the time to read the linked thread and the pull request. While the functionality contained in the pull request is interesting, it's not quite the same as swizzling since it's done unconditionally at load time rather than runtime (so it's much more similar to DYLD_INTERPOSE in that sense). While this covers many of the cases when swizzling is necessary, it leaves out a rather important one where the correct method override is selected at runtime, generally conditionally.
Also, as a sidenote, it seems that there is some sort of motivation to have compiler type checks for the replacement, i.e. @_dynamicReplacement(for: bar())–how will this actually work in practice? If I compile a bundle without access to the source of the application I'm going to be loaded into, how would bar() be accessible to the compiler at all?