This is not an argument about what or what doesn't constitute a good or healthy life; it is an argument about what is an acceptable barrier to cultural access and about the kind of moralizing that goes on around supposed breaches of property rights, where such (non)property includes such things as story, song, meaning, thought, abstraction and explanation, i.e. culture. You can't inject such things into people's lives and expect to keep control of them without resorting to really horrible treatment of your fellow human beings.