There are so many variations to what you can do with fork+exec that designing a suitable "fork-exec combo" API is really difficult, so any attempts tend to yield a fairly limited API or a very difficult-to-use API, and that ends up being very limiting to its consumers.
On the flip side, fork()+exec() made early Unix development very easy by... avoiding the need to design and implement a complex spawn API in kernel-land.
Nowadays there are spawn APIs. On Unix that would be posix_spawn().
> And as long as I'm asking stupid questions, why would anyone ever use vfork? If the child shares the parent's address space and uses the same stack as the parent, and the parent has to block, how is that different from a function call (other than being more expensive)?
(Not a stupid question.)
You'd use vfork() only to finish setting up the child side before it execs, and the reason you'd use vfork() instead of fork() is that vfork()'s semantics permit a very high performance implementation while fork()'s semantics necessarily preclude a high performance implementation altogether.
> So why is there not a fork-exec combo?
There are so many variations to what you can do with fork+exec that designing a suitable "fork-exec combo" API is really difficult, so any attempts tend to yield a fairly limited API or a very difficult-to-use API, and that ends up being very limiting to its consumers.
On the flip side, fork()+exec() made early Unix development very easy by... avoiding the need to design and implement a complex spawn API in kernel-land.
Nowadays there are spawn APIs. On Unix that would be posix_spawn().
> And as long as I'm asking stupid questions, why would anyone ever use vfork? If the child shares the parent's address space and uses the same stack as the parent, and the parent has to block, how is that different from a function call (other than being more expensive)?
(Not a stupid question.)
You'd use vfork() only to finish setting up the child side before it execs, and the reason you'd use vfork() instead of fork() is that vfork()'s semantics permit a very high performance implementation while fork()'s semantics necessarily preclude a high performance implementation altogether.