As a Windows sysadmin AppData has been an unmitigated shit show forever.
Developers (including those inside Microsoft) don't give a damn about how Microsoft intends anything to work, and AppData has become a dumping ground of software installs to end-run IT departments. A lot of malware dumps into there but good luck limiting execution from that directory hierarchy because all your business-critical end user communication apps live there now too.
The functionality of roaming users profiles (i.e. registry settings "following" you to a different computer, which gives a really slick user experience when it works) was completely ruined by devs dumping piles of small files into "AppData\Roaming" (and completely not understanding that "AppData\Local" even exists, let alone what it's for).
In Windows 2000-land you could redirect AppData to a UNC path and mostly get around this behavior. That's not really "a thing" anymore because you've got apps like Microsoft Teams storing sizable databases in these locations and getting really, really cranky if network connectivity is interrupted.
Windows development betrays its legacy DOS parentage even for devs who never lived thru that era. There were no rules. There was no adult supervision. There was poor documentation of APIs so you just hacked something together that worked well-enough. Periodically Microsoft tries to start over (all the APIs w/ "2" at the end, et. al.) and the cycle repeats.
> was completely ruined by devs dumping piles of small files into "AppData\Roaming" (and completely not understanding that "AppData\Local" even exists, let alone what it's for
As someone who only occasionally uses Windows, I think `%AppData%` sending you to `~\AppData\Roaming` doesn't help.
A maintainer can patch the package to store it configuration files into a XDG directory, then upstream the patch. If none of maintainers did this, then problem is deeper.
Developers (including those inside Microsoft) don't give a damn about how Microsoft intends anything to work, and AppData has become a dumping ground of software installs to end-run IT departments. A lot of malware dumps into there but good luck limiting execution from that directory hierarchy because all your business-critical end user communication apps live there now too.
The functionality of roaming users profiles (i.e. registry settings "following" you to a different computer, which gives a really slick user experience when it works) was completely ruined by devs dumping piles of small files into "AppData\Roaming" (and completely not understanding that "AppData\Local" even exists, let alone what it's for).
In Windows 2000-land you could redirect AppData to a UNC path and mostly get around this behavior. That's not really "a thing" anymore because you've got apps like Microsoft Teams storing sizable databases in these locations and getting really, really cranky if network connectivity is interrupted.
Windows development betrays its legacy DOS parentage even for devs who never lived thru that era. There were no rules. There was no adult supervision. There was poor documentation of APIs so you just hacked something together that worked well-enough. Periodically Microsoft tries to start over (all the APIs w/ "2" at the end, et. al.) and the cycle repeats.