The one on Reddit is fairly generic. The real one on the site is downright ugly: http://eligibleapp.com/

Could you please elaborate as to why you think so? I'm not trying to be a contrarian here. I'm asking because I'm a backend engineer so my opinions on design admittedly isn't very sophisticated.

It's not so much bad, per se, as it is just... well... inert. There's no there, there.

Presumably there would have been some further iterations and back and forth between the client and the designer had the contract continued.