Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I saw a poster like this yesterday: "Change it, Avoid it, Accept it. Complaining is just victimizing yourself."


I call bullshit to the highest rank on that line. A complaint gets eyeballs on the problem, a complaint opens ears to the problem.

Complaining is not whining. Complaining is not furtive. Complaining is speaking up.


Hm. Proposing reasonable alternatives is speaking up. Suggesting changes to the process opens ears to the problem. Complaining is whining, unproductive and corrosive to discussion.

I call BS on the attitude that complaining is really a public service, that its done with the highest motives. Its done to vent, to gain sympathy, to feel better. Not to help.


Or it may just be a matter of perspective; a manager might call a customer raising a complaint about terrible service someone whining for rebates on their next meal. Does the customer see it that way? Are they venting to feel better or are they making a complaint because they want to redress a failure to deliver qualitatively on their expectation as patrons? Is it both?

Is asking to be escalated to a manager when you call your ISP after numerous failings by level 1 support to adequately solve-to your satisfaction promulgating 'whininess'?

End of the day whatever your chosen nomenclature of "I had the expectation of X and the responsible parties failed, so I'm going to speak up about it" it's just my lone opinion that calling it "victimizing yourself" is absurd.


As long as you provide a way forward, a suggestion or solution, that's cool. Just complaining - that's unproductive.


I'd lean towards saying a complaint without ends to improve is whining. On the whole though, we agree.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: