Like many, I am suspicious of the rather overbearing claims made on behalf of the SPA architecture.
I just launched a website. It's a weekly periodical with political analysis, word-count on articles 1500-6000. It needs to carve up the content in a few different ways (categories, issue numbers etc), decorate an article with links to other relevant content, and provide a nice CMS for non-tech people to use. So it's on Django, with the regulation sprinkling of JQuery. (If it were only techies updating it, you could probably do it with a static site generator...)
To me, the idea that you'd try and force something that is plainly a big collection of pages into a 'single page' is just philosophically bizarre, like printing Moby Dick on a square mile of paper, using some amazing origami skills to present it to the reader, all in order to save a bit of effort at the paper mill.
The googlebot business is one aspect of a bigger issue, which is that a website needs to be consumable by a host of different clients. I don't see how you can do the SPA thing without making major assumptions about those clients.
Sometimes, of course, those assumptions can be justified - it depends on the job. And Angular etc are enormously fun to play with, and handled well can enable a great UX for certain jobs. But I don't think it's 'the future'. It's another tool in the box.
Relevant here, a nice talk by John Alsopp from Full Frontal 2012:
I just launched a website. It's a weekly periodical with political analysis, word-count on articles 1500-6000. It needs to carve up the content in a few different ways (categories, issue numbers etc), decorate an article with links to other relevant content, and provide a nice CMS for non-tech people to use. So it's on Django, with the regulation sprinkling of JQuery. (If it were only techies updating it, you could probably do it with a static site generator...)
To me, the idea that you'd try and force something that is plainly a big collection of pages into a 'single page' is just philosophically bizarre, like printing Moby Dick on a square mile of paper, using some amazing origami skills to present it to the reader, all in order to save a bit of effort at the paper mill.
The googlebot business is one aspect of a bigger issue, which is that a website needs to be consumable by a host of different clients. I don't see how you can do the SPA thing without making major assumptions about those clients.
Sometimes, of course, those assumptions can be justified - it depends on the job. And Angular etc are enormously fun to play with, and handled well can enable a great UX for certain jobs. But I don't think it's 'the future'. It's another tool in the box.
Relevant here, a nice talk by John Alsopp from Full Frontal 2012:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KTqIGKmCqd0
EDIT: clarification